Beyond SOC 2
What are the three types of security controls?
What are the three types of security controls?
The three types of security controls are administrative, technical, and physical, grouped by how a control is implemented. A second common set of three groups controls by when they act: preventive, detective, and corrective. Both lists are correct because they measure different things, and every control has a type on each axis. Multi-factor authentication, for example, is both technical and preventive.
By implementation: administrative, technical, physical
| Type | What it is | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Administrative | Policies, procedures, and people-run processes | Security policies, training, background checks, access reviews, vendor assessments |
| Technical | Controls enforced by hardware or software | MFA, encryption, firewalls, logging, endpoint protection |
| Physical | Controls on physical access to facilities and devices | Badge readers, locked server rooms, cameras, device disposal |
This is the grouping the HIPAA Security Rule uses for its administrative, physical, and technical safeguards. Administrative controls are sometimes called managerial controls, and older NIST guidance split them further into management and operational classes.
By function: preventive, detective, corrective
| Type | When it acts | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Preventive | Before an incident, to stop it | MFA, least-privilege access, code review before merge |
| Detective | During or after, to surface it | Log alerts, intrusion detection, access reviews, vulnerability scans |
| Corrective | After, to limit damage and restore | Incident response, restoring from backup, revoking a compromised key |
Some frameworks extend this list with deterrent controls (warning banners), recovery controls (disaster recovery), and compensating controls (an alternative used when the standard control is not feasible). The three above are the core.
How the two axes combine
Reading a control on both axes shows where a program is thin. A company with strong preventive technical controls but no detective controls will not know when prevention fails. A program heavy on administrative controls with few technical ones depends on people following documents.
| Control | By implementation | By function |
|---|---|---|
| MFA on the identity provider | Technical | Preventive |
| Quarterly user access review | Administrative | Detective |
| Branch protection requiring pull request approval | Technical | Preventive |
| Incident response plan | Administrative | Corrective |
| Badge access to the office | Physical | Preventive |
SOC 2 does not require either classification, but auditors expect a mix. In practice, detective administrative controls such as access reviews generate the most evidence requests, because they run periodically and the auditor samples each occurrence. For how auditors test those occurrences, see the four types of tests of controls.